ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access
When choosing between ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access, you're comparing two titans in the VPN industry that cater to different user priorities. ExpressVPN stands out as the premium choice with blazing-fast speeds, extensive server coverage across 105 countries, and exceptional streaming capabilities, while Private Internet Access (PIA) offers incredible value with unlimited simultaneous connections, robust torrenting features, and budget-friendly pricing starting at just $2.19 per month.
This comprehensive comparison will examine every aspect of both VPN services, from pricing and performance to security features and streaming capabilities. Whether you prioritize speed and global server access or value affordability and unlimited device connections, this detailed analysis will help you make an informed decision between these two popular VPN providers.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison Overview
| Feature | ExpressVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $4.99/month | $2.19/month |
| Simultaneous Connections | 8 devices | Unlimited |
| Server Locations | 105 countries | 91 countries |
| Netflix Streaming | Excellent | Good |
| Torrenting Support | Good | Excellent |
| Port Forwarding | No | Yes |
30-day money-back guarantee
30-day money-back guarantee
Pricing and Value Analysis
The pricing battle between ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access reveals a clear winner for budget-conscious users. Private Internet Access offers significantly better value with plans starting at $2.19 per month for a 26-month commitment, while ExpressVPN's cheapest plan costs $4.99 monthly for a 28-month subscription.
ExpressVPN Pricing
No commitment
Save 49%
Best Value - Save 61%
Private Internet Access Pricing
No commitment
Save 37%
Best Value - Save 82%
Add-on Services:
Value Analysis
Private Internet Access delivers exceptional value with pricing that's 56% lower than ExpressVPN's best offer. When you factor in PIA's unlimited simultaneous connections versus ExpressVPN's 8-device limit, the value proposition becomes even more compelling. However, ExpressVPN's premium pricing reflects its superior streaming performance and global server coverage, making it worthwhile for users who prioritize these features.
Speed and Performance Tests
Speed performance is crucial when comparing ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access. Based on independent testing across multiple server locations, ExpressVPN consistently delivers faster and more stable connections, though both services offer acceptable speeds for most users.
ExpressVPN Performance
- Average speed loss: 15-25%
- Consistent performance across all servers
- Proprietary Lightway protocol optimization
- Low latency for gaming and streaming
PIA Performance
- Average speed loss: 20-40%
- Variable performance by server location
- WireGuard protocol for modern efficiency
- Optimized for torrenting activities
Performance Verdict
ExpressVPN takes the lead in speed consistency and overall performance, making it the better choice for bandwidth-intensive activities like 4K streaming and competitive gaming. However, PIA's speeds are still adequate for most users and offer better value considering the significant price difference.
Security and Privacy Features
Both ExpressVPN and Private Internet Access maintain strong security standards, but they approach privacy protection differently. This comparison examines their encryption methods, protocols, logging policies, and additional security features.
| Security Feature | ExpressVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption Standard | AES-256 | AES-256 |
| VPN Protocols | Lightway, OpenVPN, IKEv2 | WireGuard, OpenVPN |
| Kill Switch | Network Lock | Advanced Kill Switch |
| DNS Leak Protection | Yes | Yes |
| Split Tunneling | Yes | Yes |
| No-Logs Policy | Audited | Court-Proven |
| Perfect Forward Secrecy | Yes | Yes |
| Jurisdiction | British Virgin Islands | United States |
ExpressVPN Security Highlights
- Proprietary Lightway protocol with enhanced security
- TrustedServer technology (RAM-only servers)
- Multiple third-party security audits
- Based in privacy-friendly jurisdiction
PIA Security Highlights
- Court-proven no-logs policy
- Open-source applications for transparency
- MACE ad and malware blocker
- Advanced customization options
Streaming and Unblocking Capabilities
For streaming enthusiasts, the ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access comparison shows a clear leader. ExpressVPN excels at unblocking major streaming platforms consistently, while PIA offers decent streaming support but with less reliability for some services.
| Streaming Service | ExpressVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Netflix (US) | Excellent | Good |
| Hulu | Excellent | Moderate |
| Amazon Prime | Excellent | Good |
| Disney+ | Excellent | Good |
| HBO Max | Excellent | Good |
| BBC iPlayer | Excellent | Moderate |
Streaming Verdict
ExpressVPN is the clear winner for streaming, with consistent access to major platforms including Netflix libraries worldwide, Hulu, and international services like BBC iPlayer. While PIA can unblock some streaming services, its success rate is less consistent, especially for geo-restricted content.
Torrenting and P2P Support
When it comes to torrenting, Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN reveals different strengths. PIA dominates with comprehensive P2P features including port forwarding, while ExpressVPN provides solid torrenting support without advanced features.
ExpressVPN Torrenting
- P2P allowed on all servers
- Network Lock kill switch
- No logging of activity
- No port forwarding
- No SOCKS5 proxy
PIA Torrenting
- P2P optimized servers
- Advanced kill switch
- Port forwarding support
- SOCKS5 proxy included
- Split tunneling for torrent apps
Torrenting Verdict
Private Internet Access is the superior choice for torrenting enthusiasts. Its port forwarding capability significantly improves download speeds and connectivity, while the SOCKS5 proxy provides an additional layer of protection. ExpressVPN works for basic torrenting but lacks the advanced features that serious P2P users require.
Server Networks and Locations
Server network coverage is crucial for VPN performance and accessibility. ExpressVPN maintains a broader global presence with servers in 105 countries, while Private Internet Access covers 91 countries with a focus on high-density regions.
ExpressVPN Network
Key Regions:
- Strong presence in Europe and Asia
- Multiple US cities coverage
- Emerging markets expansion
PIA Network
Key Features:
- NextGen 10-Gbps servers
- High server density in popular regions
- Recently expanded to 7 new countries
Network Performance Analysis
ExpressVPN's wider geographical coverage provides better options for users needing specific country connections or traveling to remote locations. The service maintains consistent performance across its entire network, making it ideal for global users.
Private Internet Access compensates for fewer countries with higher server density in popular regions, resulting in better local performance and reduced server congestion. The recent expansion to 91 countries shows PIA's commitment to global accessibility.
User Experience and Apps
The user experience comparison between ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access reveals different approaches to VPN software design. ExpressVPN focuses on simplicity and ease of use, while PIA offers extensive customization options for advanced users.
ExpressVPN Apps
Design Philosophy
- Clean, intuitive interface
- One-click connection
- Minimal configuration required
- Consistent across all platforms
Platform Support
Desktop
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
Mobile
- iOS
- Android
Other
- Router firmware
- Browser extensions
- Smart TV apps
Private Internet Access Apps
Design Philosophy
- Highly customizable interface
- Advanced configuration options
- Power user friendly
- Open-source transparency
Platform Support
Desktop
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
Mobile
- iOS
- Android
Other
- Router support
- Browser extensions
- Gaming consoles
Usability Verdict
ExpressVPN wins for beginners and users who want a "set it and forget it" experience, with its polished interface and automatic optimizations. Private Internet Access appeals to tech-savvy users who appreciate granular control over their VPN settings and enjoy customizing their experience.
Final Verdict and Recommendations
After extensive analysis of ExpressVPN vs Private Internet Access across all key factors, both VPN services excel in different areas. Your choice should depend on your specific priorities and use cases.
Choose ExpressVPN If...
- You prioritize consistent, fast speeds for streaming and gaming
- You need reliable access to Netflix and other streaming services
- You travel frequently and need global server coverage
- You prefer simple, user-friendly apps
- Premium features justify the higher cost
30-day money-back guarantee
Choose PIA If...
- You want the best value for money in VPN services
- You need unlimited simultaneous device connections
- Torrenting and P2P activities are important to you
- You appreciate extensive customization options
- Port forwarding capability is essential
30-day money-back guarantee
Overall Comparison Scores
ExpressVPN
Premium performance and reliability
Private Internet Access
Exceptional value and features
Related: IPVanish vs NordVPN
Related: IPVanish vs CyberGhost VPN
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ExpressVPN better than Private Internet Access?
ExpressVPN is better for users who prioritize speed, streaming capabilities, and global server coverage, while Private Internet Access excels in value, torrenting features, and unlimited device connections. The "better" choice depends on your specific needs and budget.
Which VPN is cheaper: ExpressVPN or PIA?
Private Internet Access is significantly cheaper, with plans starting at $2.19 per month compared to ExpressVPN's $4.99 per month. PIA offers better value with unlimited simultaneous connections, while ExpressVPN limits you to 8 devices.
Can both VPNs unblock Netflix?
ExpressVPN consistently unblocks Netflix and other streaming services with excellent reliability. Private Internet Access can access some Netflix libraries but with less consistency. For dedicated streaming, ExpressVPN is the superior choice.
Which is better for torrenting?
Private Internet Access is better for torrenting due to its port forwarding capability, SOCKS5 proxy support, and P2P-optimized servers. While ExpressVPN allows torrenting, it lacks the advanced features that serious P2P users require.
Do both VPNs offer money-back guarantees?
Yes, both ExpressVPN and Private Internet Access offer 30-day money-back guarantees, allowing you to test their services risk-free. This gives you enough time to evaluate performance, features, and compatibility with your needs.
Which VPN has better security?
Both VPNs offer excellent security with AES-256 encryption and no-logs policies. ExpressVPN has TrustedServer technology and operates from a privacy-friendly jurisdiction, while PIA has a court-proven no-logs policy and open-source applications for transparency.
Can I use both VPNs on multiple devices?
ExpressVPN allows up to 8 simultaneous connections, while Private Internet Access offers unlimited simultaneous connections. If you have many devices or a large family, PIA provides better value and flexibility.
Ready to Choose Your VPN?
Both ExpressVPN and Private Internet Access offer excellent services with 30-day money-back guarantees