Oxylabs Proxy vs ProxyShare: Ultimate Comparison

Overview of Oxylabs and ProxyShare

Oxylabs, established in 2015 and headquartered in Vilnius, Lithuania, is a global leader in the proxy industry, serving over 2,000 enterprise clients, including Fortune 500 companies. Its proxy network spans over 100 million residential IPs, 2 million datacenter IPs, and 20 million mobile IPs across 195 countries. Oxylabs is renowned for its advanced tools, such as the AI-powered Web Scraper API and Web Unblocker, making it a go-to choice for large-scale data collection and SEO monitoring.

ProxyShare, a newer entrant, targets small to medium-sized businesses and individual developers. With a network of approximately 20 million residential IPs, 500,000 datacenter IPs, and 5 million mobile IPs across 140 countries, ProxyShare prioritizes affordability and ease of use. While it lacks the scale and advanced features of Oxylabs, it appeals to users with smaller budgets and simpler requirements.

Proxy Types and Network Size

The diversity and scale of a proxy provider’s network determine its suitability for various tasks. Oxylabs offers a broader range of proxy types and a significantly larger IP pool compared to ProxyShare. Below is a detailed comparison:

Oxylabs’ Next-Gen Residential Proxies leverage machine learning to optimize IP rotation and bypass anti-bot systems, achieving a 99.2% success rate in recent tests. ProxyShare’s smaller pool is sufficient for regional scraping but may face limitations with global or highly restricted targets.

Insight: Oxylabs’ extensive network supports precise geo-targeting at the city level, ideal for localized SEO campaigns, while ProxyShare’s coverage is better suited for country-level targeting.

Performance and Reliability

Performance metrics like success rate, response time, and uptime are critical for ensuring efficient data collection. Oxylabs consistently outperforms ProxyShare in these areas due to its advanced infrastructure and larger network.

Oxylabs’ Web Unblocker uses machine learning to mimic human browsing behavior, achieving a 99% success rate on complex targets like e-commerce platforms. ProxyShare’s performance is adequate for simpler tasks but may struggle with heavily protected websites. In a 2024 benchmark test, Oxylabs completed 95% of scraping tasks without CAPTCHAs, compared to ProxyShare’s 82%.

Pricing and Plans

Pricing models are a key differentiator between Oxylabs and ProxyShare, reflecting their target audiences. Oxylabs offers premium plans for enterprises, while ProxyShare focuses on affordability for smaller users.

For a small business using 50GB of residential proxy traffic monthly, Oxylabs would cost $400 (pay-as-you-go) or $300 (monthly plan), while ProxyShare would cost $150 or $125, respectively. Oxylabs justifies its higher cost with superior performance and features, but ProxyShare’s pricing is more accessible for startups.

Features and Tools

Oxylabs offers a robust suite of tools designed for enterprise-grade scraping, while ProxyShare provides simpler, user-friendly features for smaller projects.

Oxylabs’ Web Scraper API integrates with platforms like Python, Node.js, and Java, offering pre-built solutions for scraping complex websites. Its Web Unblocker handles JavaScript-heavy pages with a 98% success rate. ProxyShare’s tools are easier to set up but lack advanced automation, making them better for straightforward tasks like social media scraping.

Note: ProxyShare’s features score lower (60-75% across metrics) due to limited automation and customization options.

Use Cases and Applications

Both providers support a range of applications, but their strengths vary based on project complexity and scale.

Oxylabs Use Cases

• E-commerce Scraping: Collect pricing data from global marketplaces like Amazon with 99% accuracy.
• SEO Monitoring: Track rankings across 195 countries with city-level precision.
• Ad Verification: Ensure ad placements are correct and fraud-free.
• Market Research: Gather competitor data for industries like retail and travel.
• Brand Protection: Monitor counterfeit listings and unauthorized sellers.

ProxyShare Use Cases

• Small-Scale Scraping: Extract data from regional e-commerce sites.
• Social Media Management: Manage multiple accounts with sticky sessions.
• SEO for SMBs: Monitor local search rankings.
• Basic Competitor Analysis: Track pricing and promotions for small markets.

Oxylabs’ tools are tailored for high-volume, complex tasks, while ProxyShare suits smaller projects with simpler requirements. For example, a global retailer scraping 10,000 product pages daily would benefit from Oxylabs’ scalability, while a local business tracking 100 pages monthly could use ProxyShare effectively.

Customer Support and User Experience

Oxylabs provides 24/7 support with dedicated account managers for enterprise clients, earning a 4.3/5 TrustScore on Trustpilot from 500+ reviews. ProxyShare offers email and chat support, with response times averaging 4-12 hours, and no dedicated managers for non-enterprise users.

Oxylabs’ dashboard includes detailed analytics, such as request success rates and bandwidth usage, ideal for technical users. ProxyShare’s simpler interface is beginner-friendly but lacks advanced reporting. User feedback on platforms like Reddit praises Oxylabs’ reliability but notes its learning curve, while ProxyShare is appreciated for affordability but criticized for inconsistent support.

Ethical Practices and Compliance

Ethical proxy sourcing is critical to avoid legal risks and ensure reliable performance. Oxylabs sources its residential IPs through initiatives like Honeygain, where users opt-in to share bandwidth, and complies with GDPR, CCPA, and the Ethical Web Data Collection Initiative. ProxyShare claims ethical sourcing but provides minimal transparency, lacking certifications or public compliance details.

In 2024, Oxylabs reported a 98% compliance rate with GDPR audits, while ProxyShare’s compliance status is unverified. Ethical practices impact proxy quality; Oxylabs’ vetted IPs reduce the risk of blocks, while ProxyShare’s less transparent sourcing may lead to occasional IP bans.

Scalability and Integration

Scalability is crucial for businesses planning to expand their data collection efforts. Oxylabs supports unlimited concurrent connections and integrates seamlessly with tools like Python’s Scrapy, Node.js, and cloud platforms via its API. ProxyShare caps concurrent connections at 500, limiting its scalability for large projects, and offers basic API integration with fewer supported frameworks.

Oxylabs’ infrastructure handles over 1 billion daily requests, making it ideal for enterprises scaling operations. ProxyShare’s 200 million daily requests suit smaller projects but may bottleneck under heavy loads. Integration with Oxylabs’ Web Scraper API reduces development time by 40%, according to user reports, while ProxyShare’s basic API requires more manual configuration.

Conclusion: Which Proxy Service Should You Choose?

Oxylabs is the clear choice for enterprises and technical users requiring high-performance, scalable proxy solutions with advanced tools and ethical compliance. Its vast network, AI-driven features, and robust support make it ideal for complex tasks like global e-commerce scraping and SEO monitoring. ProxyShare, with its affordable pricing and user-friendly interface, is better suited for small businesses and individuals with simpler, budget-conscious projects.

Your decision should hinge on your project’s scale, budget, and technical needs. For premium performance and scalability, Oxylabs is unmatched; for cost-effective, straightforward solutions, ProxyShare is a strong contender.