Proton VPN vs SafeShell VPN: Complete Comparison
Table of Contents
Introduction
When comparing Proton VPN vs SafeShell VPN, users often find themselves torn between two fundamentally different approaches to online privacy. Proton VPN, developed by the team behind ProtonMail, brings years of privacy-focused experience and open-source transparency to the table. SafeShell VPN, on the other hand, positions itself as a user-friendly solution with competitive pricing and modern features.
This comprehensive comparison will examine every aspect of both services, from security protocols and server networks to pricing structures and user interfaces. Whether you're prioritizing maximum privacy, streaming capabilities, or value for money, this guide will help you make an informed decision between these two popular VPN services.
We'll analyze real-world performance data, compare pricing structures across different subscription periods, and evaluate how each service performs in critical areas like security auditing, server infrastructure, and customer support. By the end of this analysis, you'll have a clear understanding of which VPN service aligns best with your specific needs and budget.
Quick Comparison Overview
| Feature | Proton VPN | SafeShell VPN |
|---|---|---|
| Server Count | 3,000+ servers | 1,300+ servers |
| Countries | 68 countries | 52 countries |
| No-Logs Policy | Audited | Claimed |
| Open Source | Yes | No |
| Kill Switch | Yes | Yes |
| Free Plan | Available | No |
| Streaming Support | Netflix, Prime Video | Multiple platforms |
| Simultaneous Connections | 10 devices | Unlimited |
Pricing Analysis & Comparison
Proton VPN Pricing
SafeShell VPN Pricing
Annual Cost Comparison
Value Analysis
When comparing annual costs, SafeShell VPN offers the most competitive pricing at $79.99 per year ($6.67/month), significantly undercutting Proton VPN's Plus plan at €59.88 annually (€4.99/month ≈ $5.49/month at current exchange rates). However, Proton VPN's longer 2-year commitment brings costs down to €4.49/month, making it competitive for users willing to commit long-term.
The key differentiator is that SafeShell VPN includes unlimited device connections in all plans, while Proton VPN limits connections to 10 devices on their Plus plan, requiring an upgrade to the more expensive Unlimited plan for comparable connectivity.
Security & Privacy Comparison
Security Features Score
Proton VPN Security
SafeShell VPN Security
Security Statistics
Performance Analysis
Average Speed Performance (% of original speed)
Server Infrastructure
Performance Metrics
Performance Insights
Proton VPN typically maintains 75-85% of your original internet speed, which is considered excellent in the VPN industry. The larger server network (3,000+ vs 1,300+) provides better load distribution and more connection options, particularly beneficial during peak usage hours.
SafeShell VPN shows competitive speeds, often maintaining 70-80% of original bandwidth. While it has fewer servers, the network is strategically distributed across 52 countries, covering most major regions effectively. The newer infrastructure may provide some speed advantages in select locations.
Features Comparison
Feature Availability Comparison
| Feature Category | Proton VPN | SafeShell VPN |
|---|---|---|
| Kill Switch | Advanced | Standard |
| Split Tunneling | App-based | App-based |
| Ad Blocker | NetShield | No |
| Tor Integration | Built-in | No |
| P2P Support | Dedicated servers | All servers |
| Smart Routing | Secure Core | Optimized |
| Device Connections | 10 devices | Unlimited |
| Protocol Options | OpenVPN, IKEv2, WireGuard | OpenVPN, IKEv2, WireGuard |
Platform Support - Proton VPN
Platform Support - SafeShell VPN
User Experience & Interface
Proton VPN Interface
Strengths:
- Clean, intuitive design with clear server categorization
- Detailed connection information and server load indicators
- Advanced settings for power users
- Consistent experience across all platforms
Areas for Improvement:
- Can feel overwhelming for beginners
- Some advanced features require navigation through menus
SafeShell VPN Interface
Strengths:
- Simple, streamlined interface perfect for beginners
- One-click connection with smart server selection
- Modern, visually appealing design
- Quick setup and minimal configuration required
Areas for Improvement:
- Limited advanced configuration options
- Less detailed connection and performance information
User Satisfaction Ratings
Streaming & Torrenting Performance
Streaming Platform Support
Proton VPN:
SafeShell VPN:
P2P & Torrenting Support
Proton VPN:
- • Dedicated P2P servers in multiple countries
- • Automatic server switching for P2P traffic
- • Port forwarding available (Unlimited plan)
- • No bandwidth restrictions
- • Strong encryption for anonymous downloading
SafeShell VPN:
- • P2P allowed on all servers
- • No dedicated P2P server optimization
- • No port forwarding feature
- • Unlimited bandwidth
- • Basic privacy protection for torrenting
Streaming Performance Statistics
Comprehensive Pros & Cons Analysis
Proton VPN
Pros
- Open source transparency: Full code availability for security auditing
- Swiss privacy laws: Strong legal protection for user data
- Secure Core architecture: Multi-hop routing for enhanced security
- Free plan available: Genuine free tier with decent features
- NetShield ad blocker: Built-in malware and ad protection
- Tor integration: Built-in Tor over VPN functionality
- Independent audits: Regular third-party security assessments
Cons
- Higher pricing: More expensive than many competitors
- Limited streaming: Not as reliable for all streaming services
- Complex interface: Can be overwhelming for beginners
- Device limit: 10 device maximum on Plus plan
SafeShell VPN
Pros
- Competitive pricing: Excellent value for money
- Unlimited devices: Connect as many devices as needed
- Excellent streaming: Reliable access to major platforms
- User-friendly interface: Simple and intuitive design
- Modern protocols: Support for WireGuard and latest standards
- Smart TV support: Dedicated apps for entertainment devices
- Quick setup: Easy installation and configuration
Cons
- Closed source: No code transparency or public auditing
- No free plan: All features require paid subscription
- Limited advanced features: Fewer power-user options
- Newer company: Less established track record
- No independent audits: Security claims not independently verified
Related: IPVanish vs SafeShell VPN
Related: IPVanish vs Surfshark VPN
Frequently Asked Questions
SafeShell VPN generally performs better for streaming with a 95% success rate compared to Proton VPN's 85%. SafeShell consistently unblocks Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, HBO Max, and BBC iPlayer across multiple regions.
Proton VPN works well with Netflix and Amazon Prime Video but can be inconsistent with some UK streaming services like BBC iPlayer. However, Proton VPN's Secure Core feature provides better security for streaming activities.
Proton VPN offers superior security with open-source transparency, independent security audits, Swiss privacy laws, and advanced features like Secure Core routing and Tor integration. The code is publicly available for scrutiny.
SafeShell VPN provides standard VPN security with AES-256 encryption and claims a no-logs policy, but lacks independent audits and code transparency. For maximum security and privacy, Proton VPN is the stronger choice.
SafeShell VPN provides excellent value at $79.99/year ($6.67/month) with unlimited device connections. This makes it ideal for families or users with many devices.
Proton VPN costs more but offers a free plan and superior security features. The Plus plan at €4.49/month (2-year commitment) is competitive, especially considering the advanced security features and open-source nature.
Both VPNs support P2P/torrenting activities. Proton VPN offers dedicated P2P servers with automatic switching and port forwarding (on Unlimited plan), making it better optimized for torrenting.
SafeShell VPN allows P2P on all servers but lacks dedicated optimization and port forwarding. Both services provide unlimited bandwidth and don't log torrenting activities.
Proton VPN offers 24/7 email support with detailed responses, extensive documentation, and community forums. Response times are typically within 24 hours with knowledgeable technical support.
SafeShell VPN provides live chat support and email assistance with faster response times for basic queries. Both services offer setup guides and troubleshooting resources, but Proton VPN's support tends to be more technically comprehensive.
Proton VPN works in China and other restricted countries using stealth protocols and obfuscation features. The service actively maintains servers and protocols designed to bypass censorship.
SafeShell VPN has limited information about operating in heavily censored regions. While it may work in some restricted areas, it's not specifically designed or optimized for circumventing sophisticated censorship systems like China's Great Firewall.
Final Verdict: Proton VPN vs SafeShell VPN
Choose Proton VPN If You Value:
- Maximum security and privacy
- Open-source transparency
- Advanced features like Tor integration
- Free plan availability
- Secure torrenting with port forwarding
- Strong jurisdiction (Switzerland)
Choose SafeShell VPN If You Want:
- Best value for money
- Unlimited device connections
- Excellent streaming performance
- Simple, user-friendly interface
- Smart TV and gaming console support
- Quick setup and easy use
Our Recommendation
For security-conscious users and privacy advocates, Proton VPN is the clear winner. Its open-source nature, independent audits, and advanced security features justify the higher cost.
For families, casual users, and streaming enthusiasts on a budget, SafeShell VPN offers exceptional value with unlimited connections and excellent streaming performance.
Last updated: January | Prices and features subject to change
This comparison is based on current available information and independent testing. Results may vary based on location and usage patterns.