{
  "study": "vpn-censorship-event-study",
  "collected_at": "2026-11-17T15:07:32Z",
  "residential_collected_at": "2026-11-17T17:41:34Z",
  "vantage": {
    "label": "MEASURED_CLOUD_US",
    "cf_loc": "US",
    "cf_colo_code": "EWR",
    "egress_ip_label": "ip_24c91b3048e7e316"
  },
  "residential_vantage": {
    "label": "MEASURED_PROXYSELLER_RESIDENTIAL",
    "http": {
      "cf_loc": "BR",
      "cf_colo_code": "GRU",
      "egress_ip_label": "ip_c722c8bf3fb76b89"
    },
    "socks5h": {
      "cf_loc": "BR",
      "cf_colo_code": "GRU",
      "egress_ip_label": "ip_c722c8bf3fb76b89"
    }
  },
  "conditions": {
    "cloud-direct-us": "RUN",
    "proxyseller-residential": "RUN",
    "cometvpn-tunnel": "NOT_RUN",
    "proxyseller-residential-http": "RUN",
    "proxyseller-residential-socks5h": "RUN"
  },
  "env_discovery_present_names": [
    "PROXYSELLER_HOST",
    "PROXYSELLER_HTTP_PORT",
    "PROXYSELLER_PASS",
    "PROXYSELLER_SOCKS_PORT",
    "PROXYSELLER_USER"
  ],
  "document_events": 5,
  "summary": {
    "total_probes": 40,
    "passes": [
      "pass-1",
      "pass-2"
    ],
    "circumvention_website": {
      "n": 24,
      "reachable": 20,
      "tls_ok_http_fail": 4,
      "other_fail": 0
    },
    "documentation": {
      "n": 10,
      "reachable": 10
    },
    "controls": {
      "n": 6,
      "example_reachable": true,
      "wikipedia_reachable": true,
      "nxdomain_expected_fail": true
    },
    "pass_agreement": {
      "primary_hosts_agree": true
    }
  },
  "residential_summary": {
    "http": {
      "total_probes": 40,
      "passes": [
        "pass-1",
        "pass-2"
      ],
      "circumvention_website": {
        "n": 24,
        "reachable": 20,
        "tls_ok_http_fail": 4,
        "other_fail": 0
      },
      "documentation": {
        "n": 10,
        "reachable": 10
      },
      "controls": {
        "n": 6,
        "example_reachable": true,
        "wikipedia_reachable": true,
        "nxdomain_expected_fail": true
      },
      "pass_agreement": {
        "primary_hosts_agree": true
      }
    },
    "socks5h": {
      "total_probes": 40,
      "passes": [
        "pass-1",
        "pass-2"
      ],
      "circumvention_website": {
        "n": 24,
        "reachable": 20,
        "tls_ok_http_fail": 4,
        "other_fail": 0
      },
      "documentation": {
        "n": 10,
        "reachable": 10
      },
      "controls": {
        "n": 6,
        "example_reachable": true,
        "wikipedia_reachable": true,
        "nxdomain_expected_fail": true
      },
      "pass_agreement": {
        "primary_hosts_agree": true
      }
    },
    "total_probes": 80
  },
  "circumvention_hosts": [
    {
      "host": "nordvpn.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        403
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS; HTTPS returned destination HTTP error (not a transport block)"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.expressvpn.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "protonvpn.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "surfshark.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "mullvad.net",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "psiphon.ca",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.torproject.org",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.tunnelbear.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.getoutline.org",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        404
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS; HTTPS returned destination HTTP error (not a transport block)"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.privateinternetaccess.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.hotspotshield.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.cyberghostvpn.com",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "dns_ok_both_passes": true,
      "tls_ok_both_passes": true,
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "USA cloud completed DNS+TLS+HTTPS 200"
    }
  ],
  "residential_circumvention_hosts": [
    {
      "host": "nordvpn.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "http_statuses": [
        403
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path completed; destination HTTP error after TLS/CONNECT"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.expressvpn.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "protonvpn.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "surfshark.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "mullvad.net",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "psiphon.ca",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.torproject.org",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.tunnelbear.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.getoutline.org",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "http_statuses": [
        404
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path completed; destination HTTP error after TLS/CONNECT"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.privateinternetaccess.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.hotspotshield.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.cyberghostvpn.com",
      "transport": "http",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "nordvpn.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "http_statuses": [
        403
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path completed; destination HTTP error after TLS/CONNECT"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.expressvpn.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "protonvpn.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "surfshark.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "mullvad.net",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "psiphon.ca",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.torproject.org",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.tunnelbear.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.getoutline.org",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "tls_ok_http_fail",
      "http_statuses": [
        404
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path completed; destination HTTP error after TLS/CONNECT"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.privateinternetaccess.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.hotspotshield.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    },
    {
      "host": "www.cyberghostvpn.com",
      "transport": "socks5h",
      "passes": 2,
      "outcomes_agree": true,
      "outcome": "reachable",
      "http_statuses": [
        200
      ],
      "interpretation": "Residential proxy path returned HTTPS 200"
    }
  ],
  "documentation_all_reachable": true,
  "controls_passed": {
    "n": 6,
    "example_reachable": true,
    "wikipedia_reachable": true,
    "nxdomain_expected_fail": true
  },
  "key_findings": [
    "Five DOCUMENT events catalogue VPN/protocol/website restrictions reported in RU, KZ, IR, MM, and UG (historical).",
    "From USA cloud, 10/12 frozen circumvention websites completed HTTPS 200 on both passes; nordvpn.com returned HTTP 403 and www.getoutline.org returned HTTP 404 after successful TLS on both passes.",
    "TLS completed for all twelve circumvention hosts: 11/12 negotiated TLSv1.3; psiphon.ca negotiated TLSv1.2 (ECDHE-ECDSA-CHACHA20-POLY1305) on both passes.",
    "All five documentation URLs were fetchable twice from the same USA cloud vantage (frozen second URL: ooni.org/reports/circumvention/).",
    "Positive and negative controls behaved as expected (example.com + wikipedia.org reachable; .invalid NXDOMAIN).",
    "Interpretive apex check (not in main totals): getoutline.org HTTP 200 vs frozen www.getoutline.org HTTP 404.",
    "ProxySeller residential HTTP and SOCKS5h paths RAN (secrets present). HTTP: 20/24 circumvention probes reachable; SOCKS5h: 20/24 reachable; egress Cloudflare loc=BR colo=GRU (opaque IP labels only). CometVPN remains NOT_RUN."
  ]
}
